Tell Me Why: The Beatles: Album By Album, Song By Song,

Tell Me Why: The Beatles: Album By Album, Song By Song,

Tell Me Why: The Beatles: Album By Album, Song By Song, The Sixties And After [Reading] ➼ Tell Me Why: The Beatles: Album By Album, Song By Song, The Sixties And After ➲ Tim Riley – Larringtonlifecoaching.co.uk A unique combination of musical analysis and cultural history, Tell Me Why stands alone among Beatles books with its single minded focus on the most important aspect of the band its music Riley offers A unique combination of musical analysis Why: The MOBI ô and cultural history, Tell Me Why stands alone among Beatles books with its single minded focus on the most important aspect of the band its music Riley offers a new, deeper understanding of the Beatles by closely considering each song and album they recorded in an exploration as rigorous as it is soulful He Tell Me PDF \ tirelessly sifts through the Beatles discography, making clear that the legendary four were than mere teen idols They were brilliant innovators who mastered an extremely detailed art Since the first publication of Tell Me Why in , much new primary source material has appeared Paul McCartney s authorized biography, the Anthology CDs and videos, the complete Parlophone sequenced albums on CD, Me Why: The PDF ☆ the Live at the BBCsessions, and the global smashRiley incorporates all the new material in an update that makes this a crucial book for Beatles fans.


10 thoughts on “Tell Me Why: The Beatles: Album By Album, Song By Song, The Sixties And After

  1. Rebecca McNutt Rebecca McNutt says:

    Albeit a little pretentious at times, Tell ME Why is one of the few books that manages to capture and explain The Beatles cultural influence on the world during a time of great change and movement forward.


  2. Marcel Daguerre Marcel Daguerre says:

    Riley achieves what I would have thought impossible he allows us a fresh listen to the most familiar music of the late twentieth century Plus he makes it clear how underrated Ringo Starr is This book which must be read with recordings of all the songs at the ready is a must for any serious music fan.


  3. Thomas Thomas says:

    it was stupid, got stuff wrong.


  4. Joel & Christie Joel & Christie says:

    I accept the role of professional critics We ve got food critics, movie critics, political commentators, etc Somebody annointed Siskel and Ebert as movie critics and people like me listen to their recommendations and act or not accordingly Don t ask me what makes their opinionvalid than my next door neighbors, although my next door neighbors opinion on restaurants and movies and such carries asweight with me as the professional opinions do, often times Yet we still assume that cr I accept the role of professional critics We ve got food critics, movie critics, political commentators, etc Somebody annointed Siskel and Ebert as movie critics and people like me listen to their recommendations and act or not accordingly Don t ask me what makes their opinionvalid than my next door neighbors, although my next door neighbors opinion on restaurants and movies and such carries asweight with me as the professional opinions do, often times Yet we still assume that critics knowabout their subject than we do.Tell Me Why is written by a rock music critic, Tim Riley He reviews every Beatle song and every Beatle album in this book I have alot to say about this One, I am glad this book was written There are books adinfinitum about the Beatles lives and events I ve often looked for a book, however, that delves into their music and not their marriages As Lennon always said, Its about the records The Beatles is about the records The Beatles considered themselves recording artists It says alot about their abilities as recording artists that this book was even written Seen any books lately about Madonna s records The Rollling Stones Too many in the music industry are personalities with music as a sidelight The Beatles were both Personalities and Musicians Songwriters and recording artists And they were better than anybody.Riley explains why, from the music point of view, the Beatles are better than anybody Not that I understood half of what he says The reader needs two foundations to get anything out of this book One nees to know their music When Riley explains why the intro to I Want to Hold Your Hand creates a 3 measure buildup that explodes when the vocals come in with Oh Yeah I. , you ve got to hear the song in your head Second, one needs musical theory to understand some of his analysis Speaking of Birthday off the White Album, Riley notes that song sections play off one another after the main riff in A major with the bass echoing the rest of the band center , Paul s leading vocal doubling himself at the octave enters on the far side of both channels Huh This is one of his easier to understand sentances The best part of the book is its appreciation of the Beatles as musicians People rag on Ringo as being the Ed McMahon of rock n roll lucked out in being in the right place at the right time Riley exposes this misconception with their very first song, Please Please Me Riley shows why and how Ringo s drumming compliments a song, how his drumming allows the band to surge or retreat as the song requires, how Ringo knows just when to fill in a space, leave a gap of silence, or compliment a vocal, all which turns the song into a superior listening experience George always said the Beatles never hit it big until Ringo joined the group Riley confirms why Riley also gives Paul his props as a bass player Bass and drums go together underneath, while George s and John s lead and rythem guitars play on top of each song Paul, like Ringo, had an intuitive feel for bringing in the bass at those perfect moments.Tell Me Why is not for the casual fan One has to be a serious groupie nerd to get anything out of it But if you are a serious groupie nerd, and I am one, this is about the best book about the group written


  5. John Porcellino John Porcellino says:

    Been meaning to read this one for a couple years, and finally picked it up at my library In it, Riley analyzes the Beatles published output song by song, chronologically I would agree with most of the criticisms others have made he seems to have a grudge against George, dismissing most of his songwriting contributions until Rubber Soul, and ragging All Things Must Pass I m a big George fan, and always thought his off kilter early tunes made for a nice contrast to the L McC stuff and I thin Been meaning to read this one for a couple years, and finally picked it up at my library In it, Riley analyzes the Beatles published output song by song, chronologically I would agree with most of the criticisms others have made he seems to have a grudge against George, dismissing most of his songwriting contributions until Rubber Soul, and ragging All Things Must Pass I m a big George fan, and always thought his off kilter early tunes made for a nice contrast to the L McC stuff and I think ATMP is the best solo Beatles record Apple Jam notwithstanding.Riley is a highly educated musician and so he can get bogged down in jargon, but if you know what he s talking about I m sure his descriptions are enlightening From page 95 The added harmony for this line is C major, the neapolitan of the dominant, B major, pivoting on the held tonic note E as a common tone between E major and C major Additionally there are numerous factual errors throughout the book, including some that would be considered Beatles 101 he repeatedly states that George played the solo on Taxman it was Paul and he attributes Helter Skelter s I ve got blisters on my fingers tag to John, when everyone knows it was Ringo I was reading the first edition of the book, from the mid 80 s, so I don t know if these errors have been corrected since then.I started at the back for some reason, reading his takes on the Beatles solo material, then went back to the beginning of the book Around Sgt Pepper s, where Riley s interest begins to wane, mine did too, but then things pick up again with the White Album and continue in an interesting fashion to the end.All in all, it s a book Beatles fanatics will enjoy reading, even if, and maybe because, you disagree with the author s opinions It s a great gateway to thinking critically about this ubiquitous music if you haven t before, and there s a lot to chew on here There s another book of this type song by song analysis called Revolution in the Head that addsof a sociological slant to the analysis, and I recall liking that one better


  6. Terence Towles-Canote Terence Towles-Canote says:

    Tell Why The Beatles Album by Album, Song by Song, the Sixties and After is a must read for any Beatles fan Tim Riley goes through, album by album, song by song, and critiques each and every one What makes this book so good is that Mr Riley isn t simply some music critic with a journalism degree He is an actual musician himself, both a pianist and composer He has a bachelor s degree and a master degree in piano Mr Riley then has a good understanding of music theory, which he puts to goo Tell Why The Beatles Album by Album, Song by Song, the Sixties and After is a must read for any Beatles fan Tim Riley goes through, album by album, song by song, and critiques each and every one What makes this book so good is that Mr Riley isn t simply some music critic with a journalism degree He is an actual musician himself, both a pianist and composer He has a bachelor s degree and a master degree in piano Mr Riley then has a good understanding of music theory, which he puts to good use in this book.Indeed, for the most part I agree with Mr Riley in his assessment of The Beatles various songs In fact, off the top of my head, there were only three times I disagreed with him The first is his assessment of All You Need is Love, which Mr Riley doesn t think too highly of For me it is one of my favourite songs of all time The second is Ob La Di, Ob La Da While he does t praise the song, he doesn t condemn it either For me it is the only Beatles song I actively hate I don t count Revolution No 9 as a song The third is Maxwell s Silver Hammer Mr Riley dislikes the song I actually like it I enjoy the contrast between the bouncy, music hall tune and what is described in the lyrics namely, Maxwell Edison running around killing people with his silver hammer It s not one of Paul s best songs, but it is very enjoyable Of course, even when I disagree with Mr Riley, I at least understood and respected why he didn t like certain songs This is muchthan I can say for many music critics


  7. Melissa Melissa says:

    Riley offers an accessible but musically informed analysis of every album and significant single released by the Beatles Lots of intriguing and satisfying discussions of melody, innovative uses of harmony and instrumentation, and other aural aspects of the music on record.


  8. Tad Davis Tad Davis says:

    OK, served the purpose At times Riley describes the sweeping movement of a song with eloquence At other times he bogs down in an obsession with which instrument or voice is playing on which stereo channel the left , right , and center tags appear repeatedly and are emphasized as if they somehow contribute to the meaning of the song Maybe they do my ears and equipment are often not good enough to pick up the details the author refers to but it seemed to me an irritating mannerism.On t OK, served the purpose At times Riley describes the sweeping movement of a song with eloquence At other times he bogs down in an obsession with which instrument or voice is playing on which stereo channel the left , right , and center tags appear repeatedly and are emphasized as if they somehow contribute to the meaning of the song Maybe they do my ears and equipment are often not good enough to pick up the details the author refers to but it seemed to me an irritating mannerism.On the bright side, he follows the order of the British releases was he, as he claims, one of the first authors to do so and he clearly articulates his emotional response to many of the songs And he does a pretty good job summarizing the solo careers McCartney s disappointing efforts come in for particular criticism he has, says Riley, come to see songs as product rather than art and grinds them out mechanically, with one good one for every 30 released Seems about right to me There are many weaknesses in Riley s approach But the job of the book, for me, was to provide something to read as I listened to all the albums and tracks in order It did that job quite well It gave me a perspective other than my own, which is all I wanted I don t see it as anythingthan a beginning, though other books with a similar track by track commentary are beckoning.UPDATE I meant to comment on something I found odd His antipathy to George is nothing to his antipathy to the producer Jeff Lynne Because of this, he undervalues the song Free as a Bird, which I happen to love What s curious is that Riley accuses Paul of plagiarizing the middle eight I have a recording of John doing this solo on the piano I don t know if it s the same version used as a basis for the new production, but John most definitely wrote the melody for the middle eight and he even starts it with the words Whatever happened to before trailing off into filler syllables Riley is right that the first line of the middle eight is almost identical, verbally and musically, to a line from Remember Walk in in the Sand by the Shangri las But the similarity ends there, at least in my opinion and if there IS plagiarism involved, the guilt is shared by John and Paul


  9. Robert S Robert S says:

    Tell Me Why is one of the definitive books to analyze The Beatles discography and make sense of every song that the Fab Four took the time to create in their illustrious time together.Most of the salient points about Tell Me Why made here are fairly accurate Riley knows his stuff, Riley gets a bit conceited at times although that s a larger issue with music criticism as a whole , and he has some strange thing against George Harrison I do find it kind of strange that Riley would fail to mentio Tell Me Why is one of the definitive books to analyze The Beatles discography and make sense of every song that the Fab Four took the time to create in their illustrious time together.Most of the salient points about Tell Me Why made here are fairly accurate Riley knows his stuff, Riley gets a bit conceited at times although that s a larger issue with music criticism as a whole , and he has some strange thing against George Harrison I do find it kind of strange that Riley would fail to mention Frank Sinatra s praise of Something , where Sinatra even called it the greatest love song of the past 50 years.Still, Beatles fans both old and new will find lots to take away from Tell Me Why Definitely an interesting read


  10. Duval Spit Duval Spit says:

    Growing up with the Beatles, I took them for granted They were a constant they always were and always would be One year I decided to finally attempt to contextualize them, listening to the albums in order with other music from the period As I listened, I read this book It has become my favorite Beatles book by far I don t agree with all of the opinions, but the musical breakdown provided by Riley is impeccable With each album, Riley plays his own critical analysis and synthesis back and Growing up with the Beatles, I took them for granted They were a constant they always were and always would be One year I decided to finally attempt to contextualize them, listening to the albums in order with other music from the period As I listened, I read this book It has become my favorite Beatles book by far I don t agree with all of the opinions, but the musical breakdown provided by Riley is impeccable With each album, Riley plays his own critical analysis and synthesis back and forth, building to a deeper understanding of the What and the Why of all their music This is an invaluable resource that I cannot recommend enough.Leave A Hard Day s Write and the innumerable memoirs tabloid splashes behind, this is the Beatles book for the truest of Beatles fans


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *